Use the BMR calculator to lose weight
The Basal Metabolic Rate is just a part of the energy your body consumes. Your daily activities also require energy expenditure (walking, sleeping, taking a shower, thinking, eating, cooking, etc.).
The Total Daily Energy Expenditure or TDEE is the total amount of calories burned daily and it depends on your lifestyle. Our BMR calculator takes this into account and multiplies the BMR by a coefficient to add on the extra energy required depending on your type of activity (from sedentary to extra active).
So knowing your daily energy requirements can help you adjust your daily food intake (Energy Intake) or your level of activity (Energy Output) to stop storing fat and begin consuming your stores, to lose weight.
A lower intake of energy is known as "Calorie Deficit" which means eating fewer calories than your TDEE requirements. The deficit will be covered by burning stored energy (fat).
An additional deficit can be generated by increasing metabolism through exercise: making your body burn more energy.
And this is what led to the inaccurate urban myth that states that a weekly calorie deficit of 3,500 calories will let you lose one pound of fat.
The Rule of 1 pound of fat equals 3,500 Calories
The truth behind the rule of the thumb is that it is not very accurate. Below we will explain why.
Wishnofsky's Rule
Do you burn one pound of fat if you eliminate 3,500 calories?
Remember the energy equation?
Energy Intake = Energy Output + Storage
When energy intake is equal to the output you are in an energy balance, and there is no change in the energy stored as fat.
When you burn more energy (exercise) or lower your energy input (diet to eat less) your body will burn stored energy (fat) to maintain its energy balance to satisfy its metabolic needs.
But what is the relationship between fat loss and energy deficit?
The famous rule that states that "3,500 calories are equivalent to one pound of fat" comes from a report published by Max Wishnofsky in 1958.
Wishnosfky asked "What is the caloric equivalent of one pound of body weight gained or lost?" and his conclusion was what we find mentioned in thousands of websites: 3,500 Kcal equals one pound of fat (Thomas, 2014). (2)
What exactly does this mean?
Wishnofsky's Rule implies that if you:
- Reduce your energy intake by "X" calories daily, or
- Increase your energy output (by being more physically active) by "Y" calories daily,
- Or do both things together.
You can calculate how much weight you will lose by adding up the caloric deficit X plus the extra calories burned Y and dividing it by 3,500. The result will be your daily weight loss in pounds of fat:
Let's see a simple example using an imaginary subject called Jane.
Jane's Basal Metabolic Rate is 1,400 Calories. Her sedentary lifestyle requires an additional 280 Calories to cover her energy output during her daily activities. So her Total Daily Energy Expenditure (TDEE) is 1,680 Calories.
Let's imagine that she will go on a diet that will restrict her caloric intake by 20%. That is she will eat 1,680 x 0.2 = 336 fewer Calories each day.
Jane will also increase her levels of physical activity by walking 2 miles per day at a brisk pace, this means that she will burn an additional 120 Calories daily.
So Jane will burn 120 extra Calories and reduce her intake by another 336 Calories. This adds up to 456 Calories.
After one week of dieting, this adds up to 456 x 7 = 3,192 Calories.
These calories will have come from "burning" her fat stores which, according to Wishnofsky's Rule means that she will have lost:
3,192 ⁄ 3,500 = 0,91 lb. of fat.
Wishnofsky's Rule isn't accurate
The rule is inaccurate because it ignores some basic facts of what happens when people go on a diet.
According to Thomas (2014), (2) reducing caloric intake without increasing energy output leads to a "two-phase" weight loss situation:
1. Rapid weight loss phase
During the first few days, or weeks the body uses its energy stores to cover the caloric deficit. This leads to a rapid weight loss because the body burns glycogen
(and each ounce of glycogen is associated with 3-4 ounces of water: burning half a pound of glycogen generates 1.5 to 2 lb. of water which is excreted as urine), protein and some (but not much) fat.
The quick loss of body mass is due to the loss of water. Water is bound up into the protein and the glycogen reserves stored in the body. As the body burns them, it separates them from the water, that is then excreted in the urine.
A 24-week-long study at Pennington Biomedical Research Center (2), the CALERIE I Study, found that the energy content of weight change was only 2,208 Calories⁄lb; of fat. This is far lower than Wishnofsky's value.
2. Second phase: slow loss
This stage can last for several months, even years. During this phase, the body burns carbohydrates from the food eaten during the diet and the glucogenic amino acids in the protein. So now the body starts burning its fat stores. But this causes a much slower weight loss.
In the CALERIE I study, the energy required to burn a pound of fat increased during this stage to 2,986 Calories⁄lb.
Although it was higher than the phase one value, it was still lower than Wishnofsky's prediction.
The body also adapts to the lower energy intake by slowing down its energy output: the body becomes more efficient in using its available energy, so the resting energy expenditure (BMR) is lower now than it was before the diet began.
Remember, your body's objective is to maintain a stable weight so it will do all it can to keep it from dropping (3).
Furthermore, as the diet progresses and body mass decreases, the amount of body tissue that requires metabolic energy also decreases.
Weight loss starts to slow down, and the diet reaches a plateau as the body balances inputs with outputs.
A study by Hall (2008) (4) also looked into Wishnofsyk's Rule and came to the following conclusions:
- Men can lose more weight than women for a given energy deficit because women typically have more body fat than men of similar body weight.
- The rule is quite a good fit for obese subjects with more than 60 lb. of fat.
- The rule overestimates the energy deficit required per unit of weight loss in the case of leaner people.
They also reported that people with more body fat would require a larger energy deficit to lose the same amount of weight as leaner people.
The reason for this is the energy content of the body's stores:
- 1,559 Cal⁄lb of Glycogen
- 1,746 Cal⁄lb ofProtein
- 3,500 Cal⁄lb of Fat
So if we have a man and a woman with the same body mass, men tend to have less fat and more muscle (protein and glycogen).
Both men and women's stores of glycogen and protein will be the first to be consumed during "Phase One".
Women's glycogen and protein stores will be gone quickly because they have fewer of them than men. So they will then switch to burning fat ("Phase Two").
Men will keep on burning protein and glycogen. But these have a lower energy content per pound than fat, so men will have to burn more pounds of glycogen or protein to cover the energy requirements in comparison to women, who will be only burning fat.
So a man will lose 2.24 lb of body mass by burning glycogen or 2 lbs by burning fat protein while a woman will only lose 1 lb of fat mass to cover the same energy deficit.